Safeguarding issues in therapeutic work with children under 18 years identifying as trans

Presented at Merched Cymru’s webinar, 17th June 2023

Introduction

Thanks very much for inviting me to contribute to this important discussion. I suppose I am coming at this topic from a number of different directions, as a former social worker with an interest in childcare law and children’s rights, and as a counsellor, with a past connection with the school counselling provision in Wales, and a particular interest in confidentiality and the Gillick principle, as well as being a member of Thoughtful Therapists (Daniels and Jenkins, 2010).

My title is “Safeguarding issues in therapeutic work with children under 18 years identifying as trans”. I suppose that sets out my stall right at the start, in that I am choosing my language very carefully here, by not referring to trans children as if it were an established fact, but as something much more conditional and negotiable (Moore and Brunskell-Evans, 2020). It may sound odd to refer to children, rather than young people, but I am using the term ‘child’ in its legal sense, that is a person under the age of 18 years. I have always thought that the law is an essential reference point in our counselling practice, rather than something which is just optional, or an afterthought. Knowing and understanding the law in this area of practice is being more and more necessary and inescapable, it seems.

It may be for some that the title is seen as rather provocative. After all, what is the issue about safeguarding and counselling here? It does seem to me that safeguarding issues, as defined in Working Together (HMG, 2022: 106) are closely tied up with the current politics and policies concerning responses to children identifying as trans.

A few examples – the Tavistock Gender Identity Development Service, which has really been at the heart of the storm over treatment for gender distress since Keira Bell’s case in 2020, is being closed down (Jenkins, 2022). Amongst the criticisms made of it (and you really need to read Hannah Barnes’ book, Time to think, to get the full background), the Care Quality Commission, a government inspectorate, judged the Tavistock’s service to be ‘inadequate’, and this was partly on grounds of safeguarding (CQC, 2021).

Sonia Appleby, safeguarding lead at the Tavistock also brought a successful case against her employer as a whistleblower, on the grounds that safeguarding referrals were not routinely being made to her. Mermaids, a leading third sector advocacy group for children identifying as trans, is currently the subject of investigation by the Charities Commission, again over safeguarding concerns (Bannerman, 2022).

And finally, my colleague, James Esses, also from Thoughtful Therapists, is currently involved in a legal case against his former counselling training institution for having his training terminated for raising safeguarding concerns regarding young people identifying as trans. So safeguarding really is a live issue for counsellors and psychotherapists working with children identifying as trans, or at least, it should be, hence this webinar.

Context and background

It also seems important to try and set out some of the context and background to this talk, and why I think it is so timely and necessary at this point. Two key reference points are firstly the whole issue of the limits to confidentiality within the process of counselling children, and secondly, the implications of the changes being brought about by the Cass Review (2022) into services for children with gender distress.

To start with the first, counsellors will generally be aware, through their training and practice, of the importance of providing a high level of confidentiality to children in their work. In the past, I have written a lot about the value of confidentiality and the need to protect this as far as possible as part of the therapeutic frame. We know that, for example, young people aged 16-17 enjoy the same level of entitlement to confidentiality as do adults, based on s.8 of the 1969 Family Law Reform Act. In England and Wales, we also have the Gillick case of 1986. This was a case brought concerning the right of a girl under 16 to access contraceptive advice from a healthcare practitioner.

This case clarified the legal position for all children and young people under the age of 16 regarding confidentiality, namely that a young person under 16 years of either sex was entitled to confidential medical consultation, without a need for parental knowledge or consent, if they possessed sufficient understanding and intelligence, or qualified as being what has been termed Gillick-competent. In Scotland, there is greater protection for this principle of qualified or limited adolescent autonomy in statutory form, as the Age of Legal Capacity Act 1991. This high level of confidentiality is important to building trust with the child or young person, and provides the basis for the counselling to proceed.

However, we all know that Gillick does not provide a blank cheque regarding confidentiality. The Welsh Government Counselling toolkit (2020) makes it very clear that confidentiality can and must be overridden by the counsellor in the event of safeguarding concerns being raised. This strong connection on safeguarding within school counselling can be traced all the way back to the Clywch Report (Clarke, 2004), which led to the implementation of school-based counselling in secondary schools in Wales.

In legal terms, this technical breach of confidentiality is authorised by Schedule 1 of the Data Protection Act 2018, so it does not require client consent, as distinct from the provisions of the General Data Protection Regulation. In reality, negotiating these kinds of issues can be very challenging for counsellors and clients alike, let alone for supervisors and agencies. We will come back to Gillick a bit later, as I think it is a key factor and a possible source of some misunderstanding on the part of some counsellors working with children identifying as trans.

Cass Review

Looking at the second major background factor, namely the Cass Review. The Interim Report made a number of points about problems with services for children with gender distress which we need to take note of. (Incidentally, I don’t see much discussion of these issues in our counselling journals, which is a matter of real concern.)

The Cass Review has pointed to the way in which the affirmative approach has become the main medical and therapeutic response to clients with gender distress. Secondly, it has pointed to what it describes as ‘diagnostic overshadowing’, in other words, where a client discloses gender incongruence, then the usual process of assessing other conditions, such as autism, eating distress, sexual trauma, all fall into the background, a bit like when we look at a gestalt picture and can only see one shape, but not the other.

The usual therapeutic curiosity of ‘well, how might all this fit together?’ is suddenly discarded. Gender distress, once disclosed, becomes the primary and major focus of the work and the relationship. This disclosure can also bring with it a whole new set of conventions as to how the counsellor should now proceed, which is where the issue of social transition also emerges.

The Scottish Government’s non-statutory guidance on Supporting transgender young people in schools (2021) defines social transition as:

Transition: A multi-step process as transgender people begin living their lives in a way that affirms their gender identity. In schools, this will primarily consist of a social transition: young people changing their name, pronoun use and physical appearance (hairstyle, clothes and so on)“ (Scottish Government, 2021: 51).

This really does need unpicking – again, I will come back to this. The Cass Review takes a much more cautious approach, clearly stating that social transition is “an active intervention because it may have significant effects on the child or young person in terms of their psychological functioning” (Cass, 2022: 67). Research into its longer-term consequences is still lacking. For Cass, social transition should not be the automatic response to gender distress.

Affirmative approach

So, from a counselling perspective, we have what is called the affirmative approach. There is a generally widespread, but incorrect assumption that all counsellors are required to practice affirmative therapy with clients expressing gender distress. This is not the case, either ethically under the BACP Ethical Framework (2018), the Memorandum of Understanding on Conversion Therapy (BACP, 2022), or in legal terms.

The term affirmative therapy rather begs the question of what exactly are we affirming here? We aren’t affirming the client’s gender – it may well be their apparent gender that they are actually very unhappy about. What we may feel expected to affirm is the client’s gender identity – something completely different. Gender identity is the client’s internal sense of their relationship to their sexed body. We would only know the client’s gender identity if they chose to disclose it to us. And this is where the problems really start.

Adopting an affirmative approach, or what I would say is actually a gender identity affirmative approach, involves making some serious changes to the way we would usually work with a client. This might include using the client’s preferred pronouns, disclosing our own preferred pronouns, and communicating an affirmation, a validation and an acceptance of the client’s experience of being gender incongruent.

For some counsellors, this might not be such a huge step, but might simply be an extension of working in a wholly person-centred way, of communicating respect for the client and building a high level of rapport. However, for me, this marks a real shift in the counselling relationship, and a crossing of an important internal therapeutic boundary. As counsellors, we would usually attempt to remain as neutral as possible, to be authentic of course, but not to try to build the relationship by overtly validating the client’s self-beliefs, for example if they expressed the view that they were worthless, unlovable, perhaps seeing themselves as overweight if they are struggling with eating and their relationship with food.

What we have here is a case of the counsellor falling into treating the client as different and needing a wholly different response from the counsellor, more like an ally, an advocate, than as a neutral but compassionate listener. I have termed this ‘trans exceptionalism’, where either unwittingly or by design, we come to treat children identifying as trans in a very different way to our other clients. This has profound implications when it comes to our identifying and managing risk in terms of safeguarding.

Understanding Gillick

Again, our understanding (or misunderstanding) of confidentiality and of the Gillick principle plays an important part here. The temptation may well be to prioritise the client’s expressed needs for security and privacy, for example by using the client’s preferred pronouns within the safe space of the counselling room. This might raise immediate questions as to whether parents or caregivers, teachers, the school, others in the family, are aware of the client’s situation and what their attitudes towards this are.

Yet, by responding in a way which affirms the client’s gender identity, the counsellor is constructing a form of social transition within the privacy of the counselling room. While Gillick affords a degree of confidentiality, it is not absolute and certainly not a blank cheque for the counsellor to work in this way, even if social transition is the preferred stance applied within the school or agency. For some counsellors, enthusiastic and wanting to be seen as fully supportive of their client, the pressure can build up to step completely outside their role, to refer the child to what are seen as appropriate external trans support groups, possibly online chat rooms, to try to access information for the client on chest binders, to offer to support them in accessing medication online, and so on.

To my mind, several things are missing from this scenario. Firstly, there are definite limits to confidentiality under Gillick. Gender identity affirmation is not a credible or well-researched therapeutic model. Affirmative therapy is designed to facilitate the client’s progression along a treatment pathway which can involve irreversible medical and surgical interventions, a task which the counsellor is not qualified to undertake (Jenkins, 2023). Social transition involves the risk of powerfully reinforcing the client’s evolving sense of self and closing off alternative avenues of exploration. Crucially, affirming the client in an uncritical way runs the risk of failing to see significant safeguarding issues which might contradict the transition narrative.

Safeguarding concerns

So what are these safeguarding concerns that we might need to consider for clients identifying as trans?

According to the Bayswater Group (2023), a group of concerned parents of trans-identifying young people, there are four areas of potential safeguarding concern:

  1. Overlooking and failing to address other issues: e.g. Autism Spectrum Disorder, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, mental health issues, eating disorders, sexual abuse/other trauma, severe bullying, confusion over sexual orientation (e.g. internalised homophobia).
  2. Likelihood that a student may take harmful physical steps to change their body in line with their attested gender identity, e.g. binding, tucking, hormonal interventions, including circumventing NHS protocols by procuring items online. (PJ: Incidentally, NHS England floated this online as a future safeguarding protocol item in September 2022, but then withdrew it: NHS England medical director, Dr Stephen Powis, said: “No one should be purchasing illegal, unknown and potentially life-threatening drugs online” (Topping, 2022)).
  3. Exposure to inappropriate/inaccurate online information and/or adult influence (including explicit sexual content).
  4. Parental alienation due to a culture where children are encouraged to keep secrets from anyone they suspect may ask questions about their desire to socially/medically transition” (Bayswater Group, 2023: 2).

To this we could perhaps add a fifth risk, that is the process of encouraging participation in social transition itself, which the Bayswater Group describe as “an unregulated social experiment” (Bayswater Group, 2023:16). Social transition in schools is not an educational procedure. In my view, it is best described as a medical, a psychological and a psychiatric intervention, strongly based on behavioural principles, which are intended to reinforce a specific sense of self, and of gender expression and to modify and change the responses of significant others, namely staff, teachers, pupils and parents. This reinforcement may well lock the child into continuing onto the next stage of the treatment pathway, much as using breast binders tends to correlate with an increased preference for undergoing mastectomy (Julian et al, 2021), and experience of taking puberty blockers tends to correlate with increased likelihood of progression to cross sex hormones (R v Tavistock [2020]).

These are not discrete and separate steps, but more like a series of moving escalators, each linked to the one to come. Each stage of the pathway prepares the client for progression onto the next stage. Left to their own devices, research suggests that 80-90% of gender questioning young people would simply come out as gay or lesbian and not proceed to medical transition (Barnes, 2023; see Singh et al (2021) on outcomes for males).

In terms of how we might want to respond, having identified a potential safeguarding concern, it is useful to refer back to the statutory guidance contained in Working Together (HMG, 2022: 106). This identifies four main areas for safeguarding children under 18 in England:

a. protecting children from maltreatment
b. preventing impairment of children’s mental and physical health or development
c. ensuring that children are growing up in circumstances consistent with the provision of safe and effective care
d. taking action to enable all children to have the best outcomes

Sections (b) and (d) would seem to be the ones most likely to be relevant to the kinds of safeguarding concerns explored above. It might be useful to quote this specific wording from the statutory guidance when considering making a safeguarding referral to Children’s Services, with evidence on potential or likely risks of harm, and any available research findings to that effect.

Yes, but…one of the standard responses at this stage is to quote the prominent statement in documents such as Keeping Children Safe in Education (DfE, 2022). This states that:

203. The fact that a child or a young person may be LGBT is not in itself an inherent risk factor for harm” (DfE, 2022: 50)

This may be true in general, but it does beg the question of what the evidence base for this statement is. Given the complexity of associated conditions which may run alongside a client disclosing gender distress, an alternative approach is suggested by the Bayswater Group (2023:19):

…a trans identity should be seen as an indicator of potential safeguarding risks and prompt careful assessment. It can be a proxy for multiple problems that need sensitive discussion involving parents. It is not a reason to remove any child from safeguarding frameworks altogether.

The next section from Keeping Children Safe in Education also raises some concerns:

204. Risks can be compounded where children who are LGBT lack a trusted adult with whom they can be open. It is therefore vital that staff endeavour to reduce the additional barriers faced and provide a safe space for them to speak out or share their concerns with members of staff “ (DfE, 2022: 50).

And, from a safeguarding perspective, who exactly is this trusted adult? Have they been DBS checked? What is their role and agenda? And what are the qualifications and expertise of members of staff who the child should be referred to within the school instead? These two sections were added very recently, in September 2022 and there are already calls for them to be removed as opinion, rather than as sound evidence-based safeguarding practice.

Other sources of safeguarding advice

The NSPCC (2022) is often used as another source of advice on potential safeguarding for children identifying as trans. I find that the NSPCC guidance is very much a mixed bag, which is sound in some areas, but much more problematic in other respects. For example, the NSPCC identifies a series of potential safeguarding risks for children identifying as trans, such as:
homelessness, mental health problems online abuse, e.g. via inappropriate use of dating apps, risk of child sexual exploitation and bullying.

However, the NSPCC is very much caught up in the wider trans narrative, so the other wing of its stance is about offering support, often via online chat rooms. There is a developing real concern about the online chatrooms run by a number of organisations, in that online moderation can be slow to respond to harmful content and quite limited in terms of providing real protection. Young people taking part in online chatrooms are necessarily exposed to views from other participants which seem very much geared to reinforcing a developing sense of gender identity, rather than a working through and potentially exiting from this process (Esses, 2023).

Gillick as healthcare case law

So, where does this leave counsellors in responding to children identifying as trans?

I want to finish by looking at some of the legal issues involved in working with this client group. Firstly, to return to Gillick, it is worth pointing out that the Gillick case essentially involved health care issues, in that it revolved around the question of whether a girl under the age of 16 years could lawfully access and consent to confidential medical treatment (such as contraceptive advice and treatment) without parental knowledge or consent.

The Gillick case was challenged in 2006 in the Axon case over whether a girl under 16 years could consent to a termination of pregnancy on the same basis. Gillick was upheld: in the judge’s decision, “Gillick remains good law”. But these are healthcare issues, not education issues. Even for counselling purposes, counsellors are not healthcare professionals like doctors or school nurses, but have simply ‘borrowed’ the Gillick case to protect counselling confidentiality. But there are limits. The examples given here point to what I describe as the permissive aspect of Gillick.

However, in other cases, the courts have applied a protective set of principles to Gillick, overturning young people’s refusal of essential surgery or medical intervention. Apart from Gillick, the High Court will always step in to authorise an essential blood transfusion, despite a young person’s refusal on religious grounds. So Gillick does not provide the child with a blank cheque to consent to progression along the moving pathway of social transition, puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones and surgery.

In the judicial review brought by Keira Bell, a young woman detransitioner, the courts decided that young people under 16 lacked capacity to make these kinds of lifelong decisions, and 16-17 year olds would need permission from the courts to proceed with treatment. Obviously, this decision was overturned on Appeal (Jenkins, 2022), but the court pointed to the very real possibility of legal action against medical professionals for authorising medical transition.

The first court cases are already being prepared. Counsellors involved in affirmative therapy would not be immune from this kind of legal action. At the very least, counsellors would be unwise to depend upon Gillick as a reason for not raising gender distress and associated mental health issues as a safeguarding issue. And safeguarding issues generally require parents to be informed, unless there is a direct risk to the child in doing so. Counsellors really cannot work in this area without understanding some of the legal risks involved.

Just as a quick aside here, and I have to say this was pointed out to me by my wife, so I can’t claim credit for it, much as I would like to, that these three key cases, that is Gillick, Axon and the Keira Bell case, all related to the rights of girls and young women. Obviously the resultant law can be framed in terms of the rights of children, but the original dynamic, the motor of change, in each of the three case directly related to healthcare concerns of girls and young women. On top of this, we know that girls are by far the bigger group accessing counselling in schools and elsewhere, and also that girls are also the source of most referrals to the Tavistock for gender distress. Just worth holding onto that thought…

Local authority guidance on social transition

And what about schools and local authorities? The local authority guidance seems intent on testing the water here in quite bizarre ways: the Vale of Glamorgan guidance refers to pupils who have “a gender identity which we do not yet have words to describe” (2022: 11). Clearly Queer Theory seems now to be stalking the corridors of the Town Hall (Moore, 2023). The guidance toolkit for Rhondda Cynon Taf states that: “Remember that a pupil who identifies as a trans girl but was born biologically male is not a ‘boy dressed as a girl’ but is a girl who outwardly at this point resembles a ‘boy’” (Merched Cymru, 2021).
I have to say at this point that I do sometimes feel a bit like the narrator of the book, Edward Bellamy, Looking Backwards, who goes to sleep and wakes up in a dystopian future, or I start to get flashbacks from the terrifying first episode of Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale, where people’s clothes, cars, everything is the same, but something has drastically changed the whole shape of people’s lives….

Anyway, it is possible to challenge this guidance and win. The Rhondda guidance was successfully challenged by parents for endorsing the social transition of their son without their parental knowledge or consent. The parents were supported in this by Stella O’Malley, yet another member of Thoughtful Therapists (we do seem to get around!) and Paul Conrathe, the solicitor who was central to the Keira Bell case, and were also supported by Merched Cymru (2021) and Safe Schools Alliance (Carter, 2021), so it can be done. The council then withdrew the guidance for review.

Over-reliance on Gillick to exclude parents

Again, this kind of guidance seems to me to rely far too heavily on Gillick in order to justify social transition: the Vale of Glamorgan draft guidance states that:

Social transition: As far as possible, care should be taken to ensure the wishes of the individual pupil or student are considered, subject to the child/young person being considered to be Gillick competent, with a view to supporting them during potential transition” (2022: 27).

I’m sure we may all have differing views on Suella Braverman, the current Home Secretary, but she made an important declaration on the state of the law regarding gender issues in schools for the Policy Exchange when she was Attorney General (Braverman, 2022a). She was emphatic that schools do not have the legal authority to socially transition children without parental knowledge or consent and I think on this issue she is absolutely right (Braverman, 2022b).

So, councils and schools relying on Gillick to authorise social transition and to not inform parents seem to me to be walking on very thin legal ice. If social transition is a medical, or more accurately a psychiatric intervention, that is a complex behavioural package involving all staff, pupils, but sometimes carried out without the knowledge of parents, then schools and local authorities would seem to be exceeding their limited powers under education law. Schools, however well-intended, are not mini Family Courts, able to dispense with parental responsibility when they decide. Head teachers are not family therapists; teachers and support staff are not usually qualified in Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, and even if they were, it is not part of their professional role.

In old-fashioned legal terms, schools and local authorities are at risk of acting ultra vires, that is taking decisions completely beyond their legal power and authority. (This requires a separate discussion, but for schools and councils to simply fall back on the provisions of the Equality Act 2010 comes nowhere near to addressing this issue of their lack of legal authority to enact social transition within schools without parental consent.)

Final questions

So to leave you with some questions to ask your still unconvinced counselling colleagues and sceptical head teachers:

  • What is the research evidence which supports gender identity affirmative therapy and or social transitioning?
  • What are your medical or psychiatric qualifications for designing and implementing a behavioural programme of social transition?
  • What is your legal authority for carrying out social transition and not informing parents?
References:

Bannerman, L. (2022) “Trans charity’s chatroom for children condemned as irresponsible free-for-all”, Times, 1st October.

Barnes, H. (2023) Time to think: The inside story of the collapse of the Tavistock Gender Service for children. Swift: London.

Bayswater Support Group (2023) Safeguarding trans-identified children and adolescents: Safeguarding considerations for trans-identified children and adolescents pupils in schools.

BBC News (2021) “Rhondda Cynon Taf council reviews trans guidance after row over pupil“. 23rd August.

Braverman, S. (2022a) “Equalities and rights: Conflict and the need for clarity.” Policy Exchange.
10th August.
Equalities and rights: Conflict and the need for clarity – GOV.UK (www.gov.uk)

Braverman, S. (2022b) “Equalities and rights: Conflict and the need for clarity.” Policy Exchange.
10th August.

British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (2018) Ethical Framework for the Counselling Professions. BACP: Lutterworth.

British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (2022) Memorandum of Understanding on Conversion Therapy Version 2.

Care Quality Commission (CQC) (2021) Tavistock and Portman Clinic Inspection Report. 

Carter, T. (2021) “RCT council ‘Transgender Toolkit For Secondary Schools’ is a safeguarding nightmare.” Merched Cymru. 23rd August.

Cass Review (2022) Independent review of gender identity services for children and young people: Interim report.

Clarke, P. (2004) Clywch: Report of the Examination of the Children’s Commissioner for Wales into allegations of child sexual abuse in a school setting. Children’s Commissioner for Wales: Swansea [PDF].

Daniels, D. and Jenkins, P. (2010) Therapy with children: Children’s rights, confidentiality and the law. Second edition. Sage: London.

Department for Education (2022) Keeping children safe in education: Statutory guidance for schools and colleges.

Esses, J. (2023) “Childline has a safeguarding problem.” The Spectator. 31st May.

Her Majesty’s Government (2020) Working together to safeguard children: A guide to inter-agency working to safeguard and promote the welfare of children.

Jenkins, P. (2022) “Calibrating Gillick in the age of gender wars: The curious case of the Tavistock”, Critical Therapy Antidote.

Jenkins, P. (2023) “Trans affirmative therapy: Engendering harm beneath a veil of protection?” Critical Therapy Antidote:

Julian, J. et al (2021) “The impact of chest binding in transgender and gender diverse youth and young adults”, Journal of Adolescent Health. 68(6), 1129-34.

Merched Cymru (2021) “RCT trans kit review is a warning to Welsh Government.”

Moore, L. (2023) Asleep at the wheel: An examination of gender and safeguarding in schools. Policy Exchange.

Moore, M. and Brunskell-Evans, H. (Eds) (2020) Inventing transgender children and young people. Cambridge Scholars: Newcastle.

NSPCC (2022) Safeguarding LGBTQ+ children and young people.

Scottish Government (2021) Supporting Transgender Pupils In Schools: Guidance for Scottish Schools [PDF].

Singh, D., Bradley, S.J. and Zucker, K.J. (2021) “A follow-up study of boys with gender identity disorder”, Frontiers in Psychiatry. Vol 12.

Topping, A. (2022) “Young trans people accessing treatment outside NHS may get safeguarding referral”, Guardian, 14 October.

Vale of Glamorgan (2022) Trans inclusion Schools Toolkit: A guide to supporting transgender children and young people in school.

Welsh Government (2020) School and community-based counselling operating toolkit. Welsh Government: Cardiff. [PDF]

Legal references

Mrs S Appleby v The Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust: 2204772/2021 – Final Judgment

AB v CD and Ors [2021] EWHC 741 (Fam)

Axon, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for Health and Anor [2006] EWHC 37 (Admin)

Gillick v. West Norfolk AHA [1985] 3 All ER 402; [1986] AC 112

R (Quincy Bell) and A v. Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust, and others [2020] EWHC 3274

Additional references for responses to Q & A session
Autism and increased risk of suicide

Cassidy, S. et al (2022) “Autism and autistic traits of those who died by suicide in England”, British Journal of Psychiatry, 221, 683-691.

Child abuse in institutional settings and the use of legitimating ‘therapeutic’ labels

Jenkins, P. (2022) “Calibrating Gillick in the age of gender wars: The curious case of the Tavistock”, Critical Therapy Antidote.

Parent blaming by social workers and the parallels with child sexual exploitation

Jenkins, P. (2022) “Calibrating Gillick in the age of gender wars: Part 1: Background to the current crisis in gender therapy”, Critical Therapy Antidote:

Anti-racism and its adverse impact on research into child sexual exploitation

Jenkins, P. (2015) “The politics of research into child sexual exploitation”, Healthcare Counselling and Psychotherapy Journal, July, 22-25.  (BACP member login required)

Counselling and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989):
Jenkins, P. (2020) “The rights of the child”, Children, Young People and Families, September, 7-10. (Open access)