On Tuesday (16 July), the Senedd will be asked to approve the general principles of the Senedd Cymru (Electoral Candidate Lists) Bill. This Bill would impose a statutory ‘gender’ quota to the new proportional representation electoral system. Our response to the consultation is on our website.
To summarise our concerns:
- The Bill is a blunt instrument that does nothing to address the underlying systemic barriers leading to women’s under-representation in politics.
- The failure of the Bill to define the key terms ‘woman’ and ‘gender’ or to refer to the correct protected characteristic of ‘sex’ would effectively introduce a form of self-ID to Wales. This is undemocratic and would breach the Equality Act 2010.
- The Bill is not within the legislative competence of the Senedd and will inevitably be subject to a costly, reputationally damaging legal challenge.
Points 2 and 3 are particularly relevant to whether the Senedd should approve the Bill. There are a number of tests that need to be applied to determine whether a Bill is within the competence of the Senedd.
The Reform Bill Committee identified the following as the most relevant for its scrutiny:
- No provision of the Bill must relate to a reserved matter.
- No provision of the Bill must modify (or give the power to modify) the law on reserved matters.
- Each provision of the Bill must be compatible with the Convention rights set out in the Human Rights Act 1998.
In our view, the Bill clearly fails on the first two points.
The Welsh Assembly has previously achieved a 50:50 balance of men and women representatives without statutory quotas. Welsh Government has therefore failed to make the case that statutory quotas are necessary and a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. This would leave the Senedd open to challenge on the grounds of discrimination under the Equality Act 2010.
The failure of the Bill to define what it means by ‘gender’ or ‘woman’ or to use the correct terminology of ‘sex’ as set out in the Equality Act 2010 suggests that Welsh Government considers being a woman to be a matter of self-identification. Self-ID is not the law in the UK and a unilateral attempt to redefine ‘woman’ as anything other than ‘a female of any age’ as set out in the Equality Act 2010, would be unlawful.
Merched Cymru’s view is clear. If MSs vote in favour of the general principles of the Bill, they knowingly agree to pursue legislation that is not within the Senedd’s legal competence.
This will inevitably result in legal challenge that will incur significant costs to the taxpayer and damage to the Senedd’s reputation nationally and internationally.
We therefore urge MSs to reject this deeply flawed Bill.
Instead, all parties should commit to meaningful, targeted and measurable actions to address the systemic causes for women’s under-representation in politics both at party and at Government level.
This should include genuine consultation with women and groups outside of the favoured circle of stakeholders, many of whom receive funding from Welsh Government and whose views and advice will inevitably reflect this.
Strengthening women’s political representation needs and deserves better than performative posturing with a Bill that cannot define its terms and is destined to fail.
For further information about the Bill visit Reform Bill Committee Stage 1 report


