Last month, the Wales Centre for Public Policy published The impact of policy and practice in education settings on the wellbeing and educational outcomes of trans children and young people: An evidence review. We have read this review in detail and consider it to be a weak and unconvincing piece of work, and we are very concerned that the Welsh Government will use it as a basis for policy development.
Baroness Cass’ independent review into gender identity services for children and young people spent four years looking at the evidence for gender interventions and urges caution about social transition, which it recognises as a major psychosocial intervention. The systematic review of evidence on the impact of social transition commissioned by the Cass review found no evidence of benefit, and nor did the study carried out by the Tavistock GIDS. NOTE 1 This rapid review is a very shallow piece of work in comparison; essentially a quick look at some weak short-term studies.
The Welsh Government commissioned the WCPP to carry out this research as one of the actions in its LGBTQ+ action plan, published February 2023. If a week is a long time in politics, two years is a lifetime. This rapid review is firmly stuck in the past, fulfilling an Action Plan commitment which ignores Cass’ recommendations and the huge shift in knowledge, clinical understanding and treatment approach for gender questioning children in the intervening period.
It is a shame that resources have been wasted pushing on with this project when research into effective CAMHS (Child and Adolescent Mental Health) interventions would be far more valuable to this group of children.
No new insights
The review compiles the results of multiple studies, from multiple countries, going back up to ten years. But all of them are single cross-sectional snapshots, and most use a child’s self report as the only measure of ‘outcomes’. In fact, all this study tells us is that
- trans-identifying children are among the unhappiest cohort, and experience more problems such as bullying and depression, and
- that children who get what they want are happy about it (at the time, at least).
Neither of these findings are remotely surprising. And neither of them tell us anything about how best to support children who are confused or distressed about their identity.
The real revelation of the report is that the research into this significant intervention into children’s lives is incredibly poor. A colossal social experiment has been carried out in schools, with entire schools pretending that individual children have changed sex, and no-one has bothered to find out how this has really affected them or their peers.
Totally ignores others
The report does not look at the impact on others of affirming a child’s cross-sex gender identity – it can’t because it appears that no research has bothered to do so. There is a passing acknowledgement of this in the conclusion:
Additionally, there was very little evidence regarding the impact of different policy and practice approaches to social transition on the peers of trans children and young people.
Even if research showed that an affirmative approach was unequivocally better for trans-identifying children – which this review does not – it could not justify an approach that violates the rights of others. A policy of affirming cross-sex gender identities affects every child and adult in the school. They are expected to play along with the idea that an individual has changed sex, for example by using cross-sex pronouns or sharing intimate spaces.
They may not even be told. It can’t be right, for example, that girls are left to realise for themselves that their team mate – on the pitch and in the changing rooms – is actually male, or that parents learn about this from their children, instead of school staff.
How are ‘affirmed’ children doing long term?
The studies they looked at were overwhelmingly ‘cross-sectional’; i.e. they looked at a particular group of children at a particular point in time, and the report acknowledges that, “This means that while they found associations between school factors and trans students’ outcomes to be statistically associated, it is not possible to establish causal relationships”. But more importantly, such studies are just a snapshot; they just tell us how those children felt about the current situation, not how it affected them long term. It’s not appropriate to call these ‘outcomes’ at all.
It is shocking, given how long these interventions have been happening, that no one has gone back and found out how these children are faring into their adult lives. Many children identify as trans for a period and then desist (more below). These young people may have very different feelings later about whether it was helpful for adults to affirm a transient identity. And the evidence may show a very different picture about whether the outcomes have been good for them over the long term.
It is a scandal that UK adult gender clinics declined to release data to the Cass review which could have shed light on how children treated by the Tavistock GIDS have fared in adulthood. NOTE 2 Their reluctance suggests the picture isn’t rosy. It would be naive to think that trans-identifying children who were experiencing significant challenges are likely to be doing any better in adulthood because they were happy to be affirmed at school. These compiled studies shed no light on this at all.
Who is trans anyway?
The review talks about ‘trans children and young people’ as if this is a definable, recognised category. In fact the only way to determine if a person is trans is if they say so. Noone knows the true rates of desistance and detransition, but anyone knowing any young people is likely to know several who have experimented with a trans identity and then set it aside, usually when they leave school or change schools (meaning that their original schools may not be aware of what happened subsequently).
Are those children ‘trans children’? Were they a trans child and then they weren’t? Are those children really helped by a policy of temporarily pretending they have changed sex, or have no sex, affirming their beliefs and ushering them into opposite sex spaces?
Of course, the review can duck this question altogether because the studies are cross sectional. How would you evaluate the effects of affirming a trans identity on a child who no longer identifies as trans? Would they be excluded from the study because they are not trans? How might a girl feel a few years down the line about adults encouraging them to believe they were truly a boy, and enabling them, for example, to play rugby with the boys or use the boys’ toilets because that’s what they wanted at the time? None of the research included in this review has bothered to find out. This review cannot assess any long-term effects, positive or negative.
A majority of the studies are from the US. Some of the children included in these studies will have been medicalised, including, for example, cross-sex hormones or double mastectomies. (In the US children aged under 18 have had gender surgeries, mostly double mastectomy.) The results from these studies cannot be read across into a UK context, where children have not received such treatments.
Since ‘trans’ is so difficult to define, different studies will have defined their study population in different ways. Some of the studies conflate “trans” and “queer” and include same-sex attracted children in the latter, meaning that children may be bullied because they are same-sex attracted, but labelled “queer”.
Schools need robust anti-bullying policies in place which protect children, including those who may grow up to be gay. Schools need to teach the law in the UK, and make sure pupils understand what rights and protections gay people have. A catch-all category of “queer” or conflating “gay” with “trans” muddies the issue, and does not help to protect children bullied for being gay.
In fact, a curriculum that teaches children that people who don’t conform with gender stereotypes might in fact be the opposite sex in some way is likely to be especially harmful to these children.
Self report – are children really the best judge of how they’re doing globally?
The studies rely on children’s self-reports about their experiences and how they’re doing, without external verification from teachers, parents or other third parties on how they’re functioning in their daily life. Distressed children may not have a clear perspective on how they’re doing and are not likely to be the best judges of what helps them.
A person addicted to opioid painkillers would likely give a good review to the doctor who wrote them a new prescription, and a bad one to a doctor who asked them searching questions about their drug use, or suggested trying a different approach to pain management. Distressed people are not good judges of what is best for them in the longer term, and this applies even more to children and adolescents, who, quite understandably, think in shorter time frames. They are unlikely to understand safeguarding, or think about the implications of their actions on others.
The studies highlight a number of ways that trans identifying children report they are not doing well. There is no question that this cohort includes many who are vulnerable and need help; for example the studies highlight that ‘trans students’ report more peer victimisation and negative mental health outcomes and are doing less well educationally. But the report does not acknowledge the possibility that poor mental health or bullying might be a contributing factor to a trans identity, rather than a result.
Trans-identifying children have been coached by activists to feel attacked or ‘unsafe’ if others fail to affirm their identity and ‘misgender’ or ‘deadname’ them. We can’t take evidence that this group is doing poorly and believe it’s because others don’t support their gender identity and treat it as evidence that affirming that gender identity will help them.
Pretends there’s only one form of ‘support’ – unquestioning affirmation
The review contrasts two approaches (see Table 1), ‘affirmative approaches’ with changes of pronoun, names, dress code, access to opposite sex facilities and sports, and ‘non affirmative’. The second approach is characterised as no accommodation at all, including no access to gender-neutral changing or toilet facilities. This is an unrealistic comparison – in practice there are a whole range of responses and accommodations a school can make while protecting a trans-identified child and their peers.
The conclusions correctly identify that children do better when they feel supported. However, schools do not need to validate trans identities or violate the rights of other children in order to support children.
Additional separate toilets or changing provision, gender neutral uniforms, informal nicknames, and crucially, a firm line on any form of bullying or harassment are all ways that children can be supported while safeguarding and rights are protected. A positive, inclusive school culture should support all the children.
Activist groups are doing real harm by coaching children that such approaches mean that they are not supported, and that ‘support’ can only mean enthusiastic affirmation of a cross-sex identity, at the expense of others.
Firstly, trans-identifying children, particularly girls, often aren’t even asking for access to boys’ sports or changing rooms. They do understand that this would put them at risk. A policy that normalises access to opposite sex facilities pushes children to demand things they don’t even want, and which are dangerous for them. Secondly, encouraging already-vulnerable children to believe that they are ‘unsupported’ if schools don’t fulfil these specific demands is likely to do further harm to their mental health and wellbeing.
Activist language, activist points
The review takes an ideological position from the title onwards, with its assumption that ‘trans young people’ are a coherent group that can be identified and studied. The search strategies, with terms such as ‘demigender’, ‘trans oppressive’, and ‘gender creative’ seem crafted to pick up research with a similarly ideological starting point.
The report throughout uses terminology such as ‘cisgender’ and ‘sex assigned at birth’ or ‘gender assigned at birth’ without acknowledging that these are contested terms, with no basis in science or law, and which are offensive to many. This is not a neutral position to take and not compatible with the need for schools to be pluralistic, as required by the Wales RSE Code 2020. .
The glossary is highly ideological. For example, the definition of sex does not mention male or female (these are included under ‘gender’), and says that, “Currently in the UK, only two sexes can be recorded at birth, which excludes intersex people.” This is an activist position, and not at all relevant to the question at hand: how schools should treat developmentally normal children who believe themselves to be in some way the opposite sex, or no sex. It is also scientifically inaccurate, as people born with Differences of Sexual Development are still male or female and to suggest otherwise is deeply offensive.
The section on policy context states that, “International clinical guidelines increasingly advocate for a gender-affirming approach.” This is not true. As well as the UK, Sweden, Norway, Finland, Denmark and the US have all moved away from gender-affirming health approaches for children. The statement may refer to the International guidelines issued by WPATH. This is an activist organisation, not a credible source of evidence-based medical guidance. Its most recent guidelines include a section on care for people with eunuch identities.
In conclusion, this review is a superficial and ideologically-driven piece of work. It has the potential to do real harm by suggesting that there’s any kind of evidence base for social transition in schools. The Welsh Government has wasted valuable resources on it and we urge Ministers not to compound this error by using it as a basis for policy development.
Notes
The GIDS team also found no benefit to social transition: “ Overall, there were no significant effects of social transition or name change on mental health status.” Morandini, J.S., Kelly, A., de Graaf, N.M. et al. Is Social Gender Transition Associated with Mental Health Status in Children and Adolescents with Gender Dysphoria?. Arch Sex Behav 52, 1045–1060 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-023-02588-5
2/ Cass Review p33 “A strand of research commissioned by the Review was a quantitative data linkage study. The aim of this study was to fill some of the gaps in follow-up data for the approximately 9,000 young people who have been through GIDS. This would help to develop a stronger evidence base about the types of support and interventions received and longer-term outcomes. This required cooperation of GIDS and the NHS adult gender services. In January 2024, the Review received a letter from NHS England stating that, despite efforts to encourage the participation of the NHS gender clinics, the necessary cooperation had not been forthcoming.”