It’s common for ageing people to think they grew up in a golden age, and Gen Xers like myself are possibly the worst for it. But when I think of my youth, it’s not just the music I revisit with bittersweet nostalgia – it’s the sex. I didn’t appreciate enough at the time, but the sexual culture I grew up in was a cultural sweet spot, occurring right after the sexual revolution and the second wave of feminist activism of the 1970s.
At that time, if I’d have heard the term ‘mirror neuron’ I would have thought it was some alien invader from Dr Who. And hormones were just what I took every day, from a green foil packet from 16 years of age to prevent pregnancy. I didn’t understand the neurochemistry of sexual arousal. But, god, I understood what good sex felt like. I remember, vividly, lying with a man in bed made of pallets, in a squat, air thick with the smell of a dusty calor gas heater and Moroccan hash. It was a Monday, and I’d picked him up at a club on Saturday night.
We’d been in bed ever since, more or less. Languorously, during one refractory period, a cigarette in my mouth, I ran my fingers over his pale arm, the black hairs bristling at my touch, and I felt the same feeling prickle across my own arm, as if had echoed from his. “Do you feel that?” I said. He felt it too, he said – that at this point, each touch between us was mirrored. We’d created an erotic feedback loop. It’s not that I’d found true love. It was just the first time I’d noticed this experience.
In fact, I picked my clothes back off the floor on the Tuesday, went to go and sign on at the Jobcentre and never saw him again. It was 1991 and no-one in the slum of rundown bedsits and squats I was living in at the time had phones. If you wanted to see someone again, you hung out in the pub or club where you’d met them, and maybe they’d turn up again, or maybe you’d find someone else. It was all good.
I was single again in the first half of the 2000s after a long-term relationship petered out. At first, I thought myself fortunate to be well preserved enough to ‘date’ (as they were calling it now) younger men, with full heads of hair and flat bellies. But I found myself in a brave new world. The young men I found might have been charming and intelligent, attractive and healthy, but sex was mechanical and disconnected, lacking any of the fluidity, responsiveness and spontaneity I remembered. It was not good.
But why? I’d read my Dworkin. She had prophesied this cultural turn with chilling accuracy. The conditions that formed male sexuality had changed. Porn had moved from the top shelf; it was an ambient hyper-stimulus in a hyperconnected world. With a limitless buffet of stimulus came a different sexual training, particularly impactful on young men: arousal without attunement, pleasure without connection and sexuality organised around novelty rather than reciprocity; the dynamics of the doer, and the done-to.
This was all a far cry from the easy, mutual exploration that I’d been used to, the easy flow, the shared understanding. Instead it felt like a tickbox exercise. I realised I was not a partner in these exchanges: I was a prop used to re-enact scenarios seen via a small screen, and mentally hoarded away for later use. I was gym equipment for a preplanned workout. The neurons of these young men were not used to firing in response to physical proximity, mutual, synchronic arousal and sensual touch. They had been shaped through exaggerated and overwhelmingly misogynistic fictions. It wasn’t good for them either, it seemed. They seemed to grind out their climaxes out arduously rather than succumb to them blissfully. Sexually, they were burned out. Trained on porn rather than the full sensual experience of connecting with another human, they didn’t even know what they were missing.
Jo Bartosch and Rob Jessel’s book Pornocracy shows that this is not just the griping of a nostalgic middle-aged woman, but Dworkin’s prophecies being played on an industrial scale. I recently attended the Pornocracy book launch in Cardiff, organised by Merched Cymru, where Jo and Rob discussed their work. Rob pointed out that the kind of burnout I had sensed was often dealt with by even more porn use: men seeking out more extreme material, longer sessions of masturbation to maintain the orgasms they’d become used to. Meanwhile, women are increasingly avoiding sex for the sake of maintaining their boundaries, or shaping themselves around porn-fuelled desires. Men are participants rather than victims in this cultural turn, but, still, their sexualities are being hijacked and monetised in a culture which normalises porn use.
As the Baroness Bertin’s independent Pornography Review states, porn platforms are designed to to maximise user engagement, through algorithmic recommendations which push more divisive, polarised, shocking content. It is difficult to imagine, but the content available online for free is merely the enticement to harder stuff, feeding an addiction that escalates into fetishes, where the thrill that comes from mutual sexual attraction is replaced with other forms of physiological arousal: disgust, hatred, shame and aggression, inevitably wrapped up in misogyny and racism. Horrifyingly, it often involves the sexualisation of children and incest. Horrendous abuses are normalised, all to keep sexual frisson alive in the porn-depleted libido. And yet, some teaching guides in Wales have presented porn as a ‘harmless treat’, like a jam doughnut on the bus home from school.
Pornocracy’s conclusions are chilling: we are generations deep into porn culture, and people like myself who remember what sexuality was like before will soon be an endangered species. It’s not a private problem of taste or morality, but a political and economic one: sexuality reorganised by platforms that profit from escalation, novelty and the alienation of sex from sensuality and connection. Joyless, compulsive and performative sex are the hallmarks of a neo-liberal war on intimacy. If those of us who remember a different erotic economy sound nostalgic, it is only because we have a point of comparison. Porn has not liberated sexuality. It has replaced it. We need to reclaim it.


