Closing date: Wednesday 30th September 2026
The EHRC consultation on its new technical guidance for schools closes next week. As many of us as possible should respond. Responses are submitted through an online survey, and you do not need to answer every question. The consultation draft has several serious issues.
There is separate guidance for Wales, Scotland and England because there are differences in education policy, how schools are run and other relevant legislation. The main concerns are similar for each country and both Sex Matters and Transgender Trend have produced detailed information and guidelines for how to respond to the English consultation. They are worth looking at before responding because most of the key points are relevant to the Wales version, even if the policy context is different.
Responding to the consultation in Wales is arguably more important because of Welsh Government’s policy stance and the fact that we don’t have any current guidance for schools on what they describe as ‘trans inclusion’.
While the guidance in England will link with that in Keeping Children Safe in Education (KCSIE – now considered to be vastly improved), we have a different document – Keeping Learners Safe. The technical guidance covers all protected characteristics apart from age, and it should be in line with the Equality Act 2010 and be easy for schools to understand and follow. The consultation draft isn’t and doesn’t give clarity to schools and local authorities.
The final version of the EHRC’s technical guidance will inform what Welsh Government says in their own guidance on ‘trans inclusion’ in schools when it’s finally issued, so it’s crucial that it is improved. At present it still bears the hallmarks of activist influence.
Among our concerns are:
Legal clarity and balancing rights. Although the draft acknowledges the For Women Supreme Court judgment, its examples are confusing and do not reflect the Court’s clarification. It gives inadequate consideration to balancing the rights of all pupils—especially girls—and fails to provide schools with clear guidance.
Sex, language and affirmation. The protected characteristic of sex is given insufficient consideration. The draft uses the confusing and ideologically-loaded terms ‘trans boy’ and ‘trans girl’, implying that sex can be changed, that the chosen identity is permanent and that pupils questioning their gender should be socially transitioned, affirmed by their school and no longer treated as members of their own sex. This approach is outdated, particularly in light of the Cass Review and the clarification of the law. There is little consideration of the extent of the impact on other learners of conforming to this requirement.
Sport and physical education. The draft’s treatment of sport is wholly inadequate. It barely addresses schools’ legal obligation to ensure that girls receive a fair and equal offer in sport and PE.
Equal treatment and discrimination. The draft steers schools towards treating children who identify as trans differently from their peers. This may amount to unlawful gender-reassignment discrimination against those children, as well as sex and belief discrimination against other pupils.
Decision-making, external advice and safeguarding. The draft encourages schools to permit children to make inappropriate choices and to seek advice from outside organisations with a vested interest in promoting the preferences of one group. This risks seriously undermining safeguarding and compliance with the Equality Act.
We highly recommend looking at the information from Sex Matters or Transgender Trend linked to above. Transgender Trend has also uploaded a useful general guide covering the questions that will be of the most interest to parents. If you are a teacher, school governor or have been involved in other aspects of school life, sports or child safeguarding you can reference your experience. The survey format encourages concise responses, so you don’t need to write a lot and can skip questions where you feel you don’t have anything to contribute. The important thing is to respond.


