Updated statutory guidance for schools in Wales on challenging bullying and harassment is now available following consultation in 2025. We are pleased to see that some of the concerns we raised in our consultation response have been addressed, at least in part.
In particular, we are glad to see some correction of overreach in the areas concerning gender identity, trans identifying pupils and the issue of school toilets. For example, the Glossary has improved considerably from the version in the draft guidance, dropping many of the contentious terms and ‘definitions’ relating to ‘gender’.
These changes are a welcome improvement, and we make the following observations in light of that recognition.
The conflation of ‘sex’, ‘gender’ and ‘gender identity’ throughout the guidance is still a significant problem. The guidance needs to provide clear, unbiased, legally accurate information which can be understood and used confidently by its intended audience (school staff, governing bodies and local authorities, for example). It should not need to be ‘interpreted’, and any areas of weakness may push schools into seeking advice from external organisations who may have an interest in (and in some cases a history of) misrepresenting the law, and may give schools poor advice.
Gender based versus sexist versus transphobic bullying
The sections on transphobic, gender based and sexist bullying are still amalgamated to a degree that is likely to cause confusion and lead to underreporting of sexist and sex-based bullying.
The paragraphs on ‘gender based bullying’ simply relabel sexist bullying as ‘gender based’. The text goes through considerable linguistic contortions to try and argue that ‘gender stereotypes’ and ‘gender expectations’ are something that can be completely divorced from sex. It seems to argue that any child can be targeted – for being ‘masculine’ or ‘feminine’ for example – with no reference to their sex at all.
This simply doesn’t make sense. What is being described is sexist bullying. This occurs when boys or girls experience bullying based on a perceived mismatch between their sex, and their appearance, behaviour or interests. This guidance tries to argue that “gender-based bullying behaviour” is “where children and young people are bullied if they do not conform to expectations.”
But what are these ‘expectations’ of gender based on? It is simply not possible to have ‘gender stereotypes’ that don’t relate to sex. Is the guidance really trying to say that a male child will be bullied for masculine behaviour? Or a girl bullied for having long hair and wearing a skirt? Are these genuinely problems that schools are having to deal with in the real world?
When we get to the section on “sexist bullying behaviour”, it is defined as “bullying behaviour on the basis of their sex”. But everything described under “gender based bullying” is already, in fact, bullying behaviour based on sex. This is so clearly the case that even the authors of this document stumble over their own hurdles, acknowledging: “There can be an overlap between whether bullying behaviour is on the basis of sex (biological attributes) or on the basis of gender (social expectations).”
The “overlap” is total. It is nonsensical to imagine that any ‘gender based’ bullying takes place in the absence of any recognition or knowledge of a learner’s sex.
It is further confused by a definition of ‘transphobic bullying’ which states that “sometimes children or young people who are gender non-conforming may experience transphobic bullying behaviour.” So straightforwardly sexist bullying of a sporty girl who prefers trousers, for example, might be recorded as ‘transphobia’ or ‘gender-based’ bullying.
On a practical level, if a school tries to record bullying incidents, then school staff will be very confused about whether they are dealing with ‘gender based’ bullying, ‘transphobia’ or sexist bullying. This is likely to lead to an underreporting of sexist bullying, and an overreporting, or misreporting, of bullying related to ‘gender.’ Which is, in turn, likely to be misinterpreted as bullying based on ‘gender identity’.
All of this is an excessive level of attention on the characteristics of the victim, when the real focus should be the behaviour of the bully – bullying is not caused by a victim’s characteristics. At the very least, this creates confusion in guidance which should be clear and concise.
Slippery definitions
While we recognise that the Glossary is much improved in the published version, the following should be addressed.
Gender “Gender” now seems to mean both “gender identity” and also “social/cultural norms and differences that different societies have about how people behave, look and dress.” While reams have been written in academic circles on the subject of ‘gender’, this guidance needs to be user-friendly for school staff, governors, parents, carers and local authorities. As explained above, conflating different terms simply creates confusion in a document that needs to be user friendly, and should facilitate the effective reduction of bullying, including accurate monitoring and reporting.
Sex The worst omission is in the definition of ‘sex’. The words ‘male’ and ‘female’ are used confidently to offer a working definition of ‘non binary’ (We note that this should include the caveat that there is no legal definition of ‘non binary’). However, when it comes to ‘sex’, we get a definition which is very scant indeed: – “Sex is attributed to a person on the basis of primary sex characteristics (genitalia) and reproductive functions (Section 11 of the Equality Act 2010). In the interests of clarity, adding the words ‘male’, ‘female’, ‘biological sex, or birth sex’ should not be a problem. The purpose of a Glossary is to help a reader understand difficult or technical terms. No other term in the Glossary is given a simple ‘cut and paste’ from a legal document. Something as important in a school community as birth sex needs to be accurately defined and easily understood.
Toilets
We are glad to see that the confusing section on toilets has been removed, but it would be helpful to include information on the relevant law. The School Premises Regulations 1999 stipulate that schools must provide single sex toilet facilities from the age of eight, and that gender-neutral facilities may also be provided, but must be fully-enclosed rooms with handwashing included.
External links
We’re glad that some of the links to old and out of date documents have been removed, and we assume that the EHRC’s new technical guidance for schools will be added once the document is finalised following consultation this year. In the meantime, it would be helpful for the guidance to link to the draft.
However, we remain concerned that the organisation ‘Just Like Us’ is included under ‘Further help and advice’. In June 2026, Laura Mackay, the CEO of this organisation, e-mailed supporters urging them to tell MPs to block the draft EHRC Code of Practice. This Code was updated to enable people to implement the law. The e-mail from Laura Mackay contained the following misleading and alarmist paragraph:- ”
“….trans people would be excluded from toilets and changing rooms that match their gender. In some cases, the Code would also bar them from facilities that match their sex assigned at birth, leaving trans young people with nowhere to go. It would also mean that all people, whatever their gender, are judged on their appearance and narrow stereotypes. This isn’t a hypothetical risk. For many young people, this could mean being outed, harassed, or simply unable to access basic facilities at school, work, or in public.”
It is simply not true that pupils are left unable to access basic facilities at school as a result of the EHRC Code. Welsh Government should not be recommending or promoting organisations that scaremonger, misrepresent the law, and use their connection to schools to campaign against it.
Photo by Julia Rodriguez on Unsplash


