The Welsh Government’s new draft anti-bullying guidance fails to take on board how the debate, and the law, on sex and gender have moved on in the last few years, taking a confused and ideological approach. More worrying still, the consultation seems to be trying to engineer a justification for changing the law to legalise mixed-sex toilets in schools.
The Welsh Government has consulted on new Rights, Respect, Equality – statutory guidance for schools and settings. You can read the draft guidance here, and read Merched Cymru’s full consultation response here.
Our key concerns:
The draft guidance muddles sex, gender and gender identity throughout, embedding a contested ideological approach, and making it impossible to effectively address sexism, sexual harassment and misogyny.
It’s long and complex, and not practical or helpful to schools. There is far too much focus on the characteristics of the children who experience bullying.
It’s full of references to other documents, many of which are out of date. Rather than bring the key information together, the guidance constantly points readers away, including to resources which ignore the results of the Cass Review or are not consistent with equality law as clarified by the case For Women Scotland vs the Scottish Ministers. These documents need to be withdrawn for review. One example is the School and community-based
counselling operating toolkit which directs schools to apply the extraordinary 10 Tips For Working With Trans Students by Sam Hope, which, among other things, suggests that schools “rethink safeguarding” and treat children and young people with a trans identity in an entirely different way to other learners.
Confusing and misleading content on toilets. The section on toilets is vague, simply saying that children should be supported to use toilets that they’re comfortable with. There is no reference to safeguarding, the comfort and rights of others or to the relevant law.
It is outrageous then that the consultation included a question asking whether respondents thought the Education (School Premises) regulations 1999 should be changed to allow schools to provide gender-neutral toilets.
Under these regulations schools are permitted to provide gender-neutral toilets, which must each be a fully enclosed room with handwashing included.
The inclusion of this question, implying that gender neutral toilets are currently not allowed, looks like an underhand way of trying to obtain some sort of statistic to claim that there is support for a change in these regulations without proper consultation. Respondents to the survey have not been provided with any information about what the law is, why a change might be needed, what sort of solution could be offered, or any evidence base at all. Many will just incorrectly assume that current regulations don’t allow for gender-neutral loos.
We fear that whatever statistic they obtain may be misused to open the door to unnecessary changes to the regulations as well, in order to retrospectively make the legally non-compliant mixed-sex toilets in many schools lawful.
Welsh Government may view this as a cheaper option than supporting schools to alter current non-compliant facilities so that all pupils have access to their legal rights. We will be pushing to make sure that any proposed changes to legislation go through a full consultation process, and are based on evidence.


