Merched Cymru responds to Jane Hutt’s Written Statement on the Supreme Court ruling

We welcome Welsh Government’s statement that it accepts the Supreme Court ruling and will comply with the law.

However, that is about the only aspect we can welcome of this this grudging, mealy-mouthed, bare minimum acknowledgement of what we and other women’s groups have been telling Welsh Government for years – that ‘sex’ in the Equality Act means biological sex and that trans women are men and therefore do not have the right to be treated as if they were women for all purposes.

This statement focuses almost entirely on how trans people might be feeling, yet still fails to support them by making it clear that they have lost no rights or protections in law.

There is no thought or consideration for women, no recognition of the abuse and vilification we have faced simply for holding to the truth now set out unequivocally by the Supreme Court – that sex is real and that it matters legally, socially and politically.

Furthermore, Welsh Government confirms its continued confusion about the law in stating that ‘Discrimination and harassment against all people with one or more protected characteristics are neither legal, nor in any way acceptable.’

Harassment is of course never acceptable, but the Equality Act specifically sets out circumstances in which discrimination – that is recognising differences between groups of people – is lawful and vitally important for equality and fairness. ‘ Discriminating between adults and children is crucial for safeguarding, for example. Discriminating between men and women is essential to ensure safety and fairness in sports.

This kind of misrepresentation of equality law is just one example of the gender ideology knotweed that our governments and institutions need to address urgently if they are to comply with the law and ensure genuine equality and fairness for all.

Merched Cymru responds to the Cass Report

We welcome the release today of the final report of the independent review of gender identity services for children and young people, commissioned by NHS England and chaired by Dr Hilary Cass. It is a very substantial piece of work, four years in the making, and we’ll respond more fully to its research and recommendations in due course. While some of the findings were anticipated, it is nevertheless shocking to see the facts in print. Continue reading “Merched Cymru responds to the Cass Report”

Mixed sex toilets in Wales’ schools – breaking the law

New and refurbished school buildings across Wales are imposing mixed sex toilet facilities on children. These toilets are not compliant with the law, and present considerable problems, particularly for girls.

Merched Cymru’s research shows that 15% of Welsh secondary schools surveyed have only mixed sex toilet provision, with many more having some or most of their provision in mixed sex blocks with shared handwashing facilities, which are not compliant with the regulations. Continue reading “Mixed sex toilets in Wales’ schools – breaking the law”

Questions for Labour leadership candidates from grassroots women’s and LGB organisations in Wales

Together with our friends in WRN Wales, LGB Alliance Cymru, WomenZone and the Gay Men’s Network, we wrote the following letter to Vaughan Gething and Jeremy Miles.

As groups that have been excluded from the development of policies and action plans that affect us, we wanted to know if a new Welsh Labour leader and First Minister would signal a change in approach.

We believe that these questions are critical to understanding the willingness of both candidates to listen to viewpoints from beyond the usual organisations that are called on to contribute to policy. For our supporters who are Welsh Labour Party members, this could be a deciding factor in who they choose to vote for. Continue reading “Questions for Labour leadership candidates from grassroots women’s and LGB organisations in Wales”

Merched Cymru’s letter to The Observer on ‘Gender Questioning Children’

Merched Cymru has sent the following letter to the Observer in response to this article on the UK’s recently published draft guidance entitled ‘Gender Questioning Children.’

We welcome the long-awaited guidance for English schools on how to support children who are questioning their gender.

In Wales we are still waiting for guidance from the Welsh government, announced in the Welsh Government’s LGBTQ+ action plan and initially promised for the summer term. Meanwhile schools are left without direction in this highly contested area, with many still following guidance toolkits which misrepresent equality law.

While the new draft for England is not perfect, it marks a significant step forward and it is encouraging to see a clearly stated commitment to safeguarding principles and a recognition of the rights of other pupils. We hope that the Welsh guidance will take a similar approach.