Wales’ schools still hung out to dry on trans guidance

Two years after the Welsh Government promised it ‘by the summer term’ Welsh schools are still left without national guidance on how to support pupils who identify as trans. Meanwhile old policies and guidance documents are still pushing schools to act in ways which are out of line with the law and with how the debate has moved on.

Following the Supreme Court’s judgment in April, it is completely clear that single sex spaces must be single sex. Schools and local authorities are subject to the law, but out of date guidance is still encouraging them to ‘rethink safeguarding’ for trans identifying pupils, or to permit access to opposite sex spaces on a case by case basis.

The Welsh Government and local authorities need to step up and issue clear guidance to schools that they must comply with the law and put children’s safety and wellbeing first. They also need to withdraw outdated documents which don’t reflect the new legal clarity, and are not consistent with the findings of the Cass Review.

Leadership missing in action

Originally promised for summer 2023, consultation on national guidance has been once more delayed. With Senedd elections looming in May, it seems unlikely that this consultation will take place until well into 2026. It is normally recommended not to run a public consultation in the run up to an election. Given the controversial topic, it seems even less likely that this will happen.

While it’s good news that the process is taking stock of the changing landscape, and particularly the findings of the Cass review, the Welsh Government, at minimum, should be reminding schools of their legal and safeguarding responsibilities.

No help from local authorities

Schools won’t get much help from their Councils either. We asked all 22 Councils in Wales whether they had issued any guidance to schools, or even responded to any requests for guidance.

Those who have responded so far are all waiting for the EHRC guidance, and seem to be holding off even discussing the implications of this clarification of the law.

“No information held on this matter – we have not received guidance from the EHRC, and no actions would be taken until guidance is given.”

“The Council remains committed to ensuring our policies, services and facilities are safe for all and will be reviewing policies, practices and service delivery in order to fully understand our adherence to the Equality and Human Rights Commission’s revised Code of Practice, that is yet to be published.”

Meanwhile, the Vale of Glamorgan Council still retains their dangerous and legally risky Trans inclusion toolkit, which they have said they do not intend to withdraw. It instructs schools to allow children access to opposite sex toilets, changing rooms and bedrooms on trips on a case by case basis, based on a ‘balancing exercise’. You can read more about it here: A new Vale of Glamorgan Transgender Toolkit – still putting children at risk – Merched Cymru

While the West Glamorgan Safeguarding Board withdrew its similar toolkit last year, the document is still available online via web search, with no indication that it has been withdrawn.

The Supreme Court judgment has made it absolutely clear that the protection from discrimination under ‘gender reassignment’ does not mean an entitlement to be treated as the other sex when it comes to single sex spaces and services. These toolkits direct schools to act unlawfully, and to violate the most basic of safeguarding principles.

No help from the regulator either

Meanwhile, schools might reach for Estyn’s Celebrating diversity and promoting inclusion – Good practice in supporting lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) learners in schools and colleges

This would be a mistake. Written in 2020, this document is out of date and out of line with the law. It presents gender identity as uncontested fact rather than a belief and uses loaded language such as ‘preferred pronouns’, ‘assigned at birth’ and ‘different gender’. It signposts Stonewall training and resources which misrepresent equality law, and quotes Stonewall research extensively. Stonewall is mentioned 37 times. Safeguarding only twice.

It encourages schools to support social transition at school as if the Cass Review never happened. Examples instruct staff to, ‘respect the name and pronouns with which they have chosen to identify’. One, shockingly, describes a scenario where a child in Year 5 was supported by staff, peers, and external agencies to socially transition because they ‘identified as a different gender from their sex assigned at birth’. The Cass Review particularly discourages social transition in primary school.

Throw them out and start afresh

A whole raft of documents, policies and guidance need to be withdrawn for a fresh start. They’re totally out of date, rooted in a world when Stonewall were riding high, the Cass Review had not been published and politicians seemed to think they could make ‘trans women are women’ true by saying it. But ‘no debate’ is over. The debate on the harms to women’s rights and children’s safety and wellbeing is well and truly happening, in the courts and in the public sphere.

For example, the School and community-based counselling operating toolkit directs schools to apply the extraordinary 10 Tips For Working With Trans Students by Sam Hope. This tells schools to “rethink safeguarding”, because “a trans person somehow overcoming their social marginalisation enough to have the power to harm other students” is so unlikely.

It also tells schools that they should hide a social transition from parents, and make sure that a child isn’t “accidentally outed – e.g. in letters home”.

The Welsh Government’s new draft anti-bullying guidance, consulted on earlier this year, is no better. It muddles sex, gender and gender identity throughout, embedding a contested ideological approach, and making it impossible to effectively address sexism, sexual harassment and misogyny. Read more about Merched Cymru’s response to this document.

Schools deserve better

After a decade or more of guidance and training which has misrepresented equality law, schools need help to make sure that they’re complying with the law and keeping their pupils safe. It is outrageous that public bodies are letting schools down in this way.

The law is clear, and when it comes to children in school, it always has been. Sex in the Equality Act 2010 means biological sex, and children who are questioning their gender identity must be supported while keeping them safe and protecting the rights of others. Schools need to be backed up by the government, Councils and the regulator to do the right thing.

What you can do

If you have school-age children, write to your school to ask whether they’re aware of the Supreme Court judgment, and the clarity it brings that single sex spaces such as toilets, changing rooms and dormitories on school trips, and single sex sports must be divided by sex and not gender identity. Alert them to the fact that supposedly current guidance documents are not safe for them to use.

Write to your MS to raise the issue, and point out that documents like the School and community-based counselling operating toolkit and the Estyn Celebrating diversity and promoting inclusion guidance need to be withdrawn and completely rewritten to bring them up to date.