Our response to the Curriculum for Wales Framework guidance relates to the proposed amends to the following definitions: Gender, Gender-based violence, and LGBTQ+. We outline our concerns below.
Gender: (Rhywedd) For the purposes of this guidance gender is a term used to refer to whether someone’s internal sense of themselves is female, male or non-binary. A person’s gender does not always align with the sex they were registered at birth The RSE section of this Framework provides more information.
This is a highly subjective definition of ‘gender’, which is based in queer theory. It presents as a fact the belief that everyone has an internal sense of identity that might or might not align with their sexed body. There is no medical or scientific evidence to support this view.
Further, this revised definition contradicts the defence put forward by Welsh Government in the judicial review of the RSE curriculum brought by Public Child Protection Wales, which stated that
…the claimants have not pointed to any passages in the code or the guidance that authorise or positively approve teaching that advocates or promotes any particular identity or sexual lifestyle over another, or that encourage children to self- identify in any particular way.
It is our view that the proposed change to the terminology would advocate and promote the belief that gender identity is a fact and tacitly encourage children who might be confused or distressed for any number of reasons to attribute their feelings to having a gender that ‘does not align to their sex’.
Gender-based violence (GBV) – (Trais ar sail rhywedd) (1) Violence, threats of violence or harassment arising directly or indirectly from values, beliefs or customs relating to gender or sexual orientation; (2) female genital mutilation; (3) forcing a person (whether by physical force or coercion by threats or other psychological means) to enter into a religious or civil ceremony of marriage (whether legally binding or not).
The issue is male violence against women and girls. If Welsh Government defines ‘gender’ as someone’s internal sense of themselves, then it is implying that women and girls face violence and abuse because they ‘feel’ like women, not because they are female. This is insulting and dangerous. If we cannot name the problem, we cannot deal with it. Women and girls face violence and abuse because of their sex, not their inner sense of self.
LGBTQ+ – (LHDTC+) Refers to lesbian, gay, bisexual / bi, transgender/trans people, queer or questioning. Other letters can be added to the acronym to include other groups, orientations and identities, such as I (intersex) and A (asexual / aromantic). The + (plus) in the acronym is used as a shorthand to include and acknowledge other diverse terms people identify with and use to describe their identities and orientations, including intersex, asexual and aromantic people.
‘Intersex’ is an outdated, unscientific term to describe people with Differences of Sexual Development, which has been widely rejected by many within that community. These are complex medical conditions that should not be reduced to an ‘identity’.
The only sexual orientations in ‘LGBTQ+’ are lesbian, gay and bisexual. ‘Asexual’, ‘aromantic’, ‘queer’ and ‘questioning’ are not sexual orientations and if Welsh Government is unable to define what the ‘+’ refers to, then it should not be included.
It is Merched Cymru’s view that ‘LGBTQ+’ is as unhelpful and reductive a grouping as ‘BAME’. They are groups created for the convenience of those with institutional power, which take no account of the often widely varying needs of the many different communities and demographics that are bunched together under those letters. At the very least, the sexual orientation groups of LGB should be distinct from the identity groups of TQ+ as the needs of these groups are different and often conflicting.


