One of the things I learnt very quickly as a teacher was that I needed parents on-side. Partnership with parents is crucial. Without good communication, trust and the sharing of information between teacher and parents, the successful education of a child is impossible.
Teachers are overwhelmed by the demands of large classes, planning, assessment, managing curriculum changes, dealing with educational initiatives, training, staff meetings, writing reports and ticking the many, often pointless, boxes which are part of the daily grind. We are constantly bombarded with new expectations to meet from the Local Authority, the Welsh Government and Estyn. It is extremely difficult to succeed at all this, and to get to know our pupils as well as we would like.
Sometimes, we have to be honest and admit there are pupils that we do not develop relationships with, or that we feel slip through the net. Often, we have to try and make a special effort to pay attention to the quiet ones, or the average ones. We have to admit that we cannot give enough time to the struggling ones, or those with behavioural issues. It is part of the frustration and stress of the job, and a reason teachers go home at night feeling dissatisfied or unhappy.
Partnership with parents is vital
That is why partnership with parents is vital. Parents know their children better than teachers do. They see a different side of them at home which teachers never get to know. Often, this is a side that would surprise us. A child in school may be quiet and ignored but be outgoing and lively at home. A struggling child may benefit from the support parents can give in a different environment. In the vast majority of cases, parents know what their children want and need, and are best placed to provide it. In the vast majority of cases, parents care more about their individual child than overstretched teachers with a class full of children to worry about. Working effectively together though, teachers and parents can ensure children will have positive school experiences, achieve their potential and have good mental well-being.
When communication and relationships break down between teachers and parents, it is a serious situation for the child.

Failings in Rhondda Cynon Taff
This is why I was horrified to read the story of a school in Rhondda Cynon Taff and the Trans Toolkit procedures they carried out, without proper consultation with the pupil’s parents. Not only was there a breakdown in the teacher and parent partnership, with teaching staff deciding they were the experts on this child (and presumably on gender dysphoria), there were serious safeguarding issues.
There was no consideration on the part of the teaching staff as to why the child had expressed their intention to identify as the opposite sex. Despite the parents’ statement that their child had been bullied and that the behaviour change was sudden, the parents’ concerns were ignored in the rush to affirm the pupil in their new identity. The school forgot that they are not privy to all the facts about an individual child and that parents know their own child better than busy, harassed teachers.
A final safeguarding concern is that the child, who is a thirteen-year-old boy, was allowed to do PE with the girls and treated as the sex he identified with. Sex is a protected characteristic in the Equality Act 2010 and girls are entitled to single-sex spaces. It is wrong to prioritise the protected characteristic of gender reassignment over that of sex and to expect girls to remove their boundaries.
The Stonewall connection
Rhondda Cynon Taf, like most councils in Wales, is a member of the Diversity Champion Scheme run by the lobby group Stonewall. The school involved may also be a member of the Stonewall School and College Champion Scheme. Stonewall is not an expert in child development or education – but it has a profound influence on educational policies in our Welsh schools. This is set to become more of an issue if the Welsh Government has its way. Two new policies have recently been released for consultation which will have major implications for education: the RSE Curriculum and the LGBTQ+ Action Plan. Both are based on transgender ideology and Queer Theory and are heavily influenced by Stonewall, which was involved in their development.
In the RSE Curriculum, Strand 1 is called ‘Developing and expressing identity and forming relationships.’ It states:
Gradually learners should be supported to understand how aspects of identity and individuality, including LGBTQ+ diversity, sex, gender and sexuality, develop and change over time.
Us teachers might wonder how sex changes over time?
In the document, sex is defined as being
Assigned to a person on the basis of primary sex characteristics (genitalia) and reproductive functions. Some people’s gender identity does not match up with the sex they were assigned at birth. Sometimes the terms ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ are used interchangeably to refer to whether someone is female, male or non-binary.
The definition of gender is equally confusing. It is described as a biological term, a term about identity, a term referring to social norms and a harmful stereotype. What the Welsh Government actually means by gender is unclear. Throughout the RSE Curriculum, sex and gender are conflated.
A curriculum based in ideology
Despite the Welsh Government stating that RSE should be pluralistic and fact-based, the curriculum is based on ideology. Teachers, already overworked, will have to write RSE schemes based on confusing, unscientific ideas of ‘gender identity’, ‘non-binary’ and ‘assigned sex’. We do not have the time or expertise to do this. This was illustrated recently by the growing problem of sexual harassment of girls by boys in schools.
Teachers stated they felt unequipped to deal with the issue or to teach about respect and consent. Teachers will need to bring in specialists to help them teach the new RSE Curriculum. Experts like Mermaids, Just Like Us and Stonewall who are not politically impartial, conflate sex and gender and use resources that promote the idea of being born in the wrong body and a gender spectrum of pink and blue stereotypes.
Stonewall, along with other Trans Rights organisations, believe that gender identity should trump sex and have suggested single-sex exemptions should be removed from the Equality Act 2010. This is an issue for pupils, particularly girls.
What if a child does not believe that a fellow pupil is the sex they identify as? What if girls are unhappy sharing changing spaces? Will these children be considered bigoted, or accused of wrong think or transphobia? What of their rights to freedom of thought and expression, to feel safe from fear of exploitation or abuse? Will girls be taught about consent in one lesson only to be expected to give up their boundaries in another?
The LGBTQ+ Action Plan
In the new LGBTQ+ Action Plan, Mark Drakeford has put his name to the introduction which states:
We want Wales to be a nation, where everyone feels safe to be themselves, to be open about their sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression and sex characteristics.
Does Drakeford really mean this? Can pupils who believe sex is immutable feel safe to be themselves? Can gay and lesbian children feel safe to be themselves if say they are attracted to members of the same sex, not gender?
The introduction also proudly states:
We established a gender identity service to help our trans family be their true selves.
Does Drakeford believe that medicalisation is the only way children with gender dysphoria can be their true selves?
In the Education section of the Action Plan, the suggestion seems to be, worryingly, that the new RSE Curriculum is a done deal, rather than in consultation.
It states:
Change is underway…the LGBTQ+ people who engaged with Stonewall Cymru’s outreach process were largely optimistic about the opportunities of the new Welsh curriculum.
Of course, schools should teach about being same-sex attracted, the condition of gender dysphoria and that some people identify as trans – but this must be done factually alongside biological sex, reproduction, evidence about treatment for gender dysphoria and how to form healthy consenting relationships whether straight or LGBT.
In the Health section, there is the promise to:
Commit to review the Gender Identity pathway for children and young people in Wales following the review in NHS England.
Presumably this means the Welsh Government are not satisfied with the results of the Keira Bell case which concluded that children are not able to consent to treatment with puberty blockers.
The Welsh Government seem to have committed to the affirmation route which means social transition, puberty blockers, cross sex hormones and possible surgery. Is this how the Welsh Government believes children should develop and express identity and change over time? Should children express their true selves through medicalisation?
Teachers will be expected to comply
Us teachers will be expected to socially affirm, and encourage the gender identity pathway, if a child says they want to identify as the opposite sex in school. This is despite clear evidence which shows most children will desist with ‘watchful waiting’ approaches. These children often end up identifying as gay or lesbian. Could we complicate issues of gender non-conformity and sexual orientation by affirmation immediately? Surely teachers should be discouraging stereotypes and promoting the idea that there is no correct way to be a boy or girl? There is growing evidence that puberty blockers are not reversible, safe or always beneficial to children with gender dysphoria. England is not the only country to have reviewed puberty blockers. Sweden and Norway have both changed their approaches to using them.
The Welsh Government are promoting an ideology in our schools which is not supported by strong evidence. They appear to be following the example of the Scottish Government who recently released Trans Guidance for schools, amongst concern from parents. It seems likely that if the RSE Curriculum and LGBTQ+ Action Plan pass in their current forms, then there will be more incidents like that in the Rhondda Cynon Taf school. There will be further breakdowns in teacher and parent partnerships.
Time to stand up
Any teacher worth their salt will be aware that these policies raise many questions. Any teacher worth their salt will be concerned teacher and parent relationships are at risk and safeguarding is being ignored. Any teacher worth their salt will know they lack the expertise to support and aid a pupil to make choices about their bodies that may be irreversible, especially without full parental involvement.
This is too much responsibility for unequipped teaching staff to take upon themselves.
The LGBTQ+ Action Plan is in consultation until 22nd October 2021.
It’s time for us teachers to stand up and raise these concerns.




