Letter to Andrew Woodall, Permanent Secretary

Dear Mr Woodall

Supreme Court Judgment: For Women Scotland v Scottish Ministers

I am writing on behalf of Merched Cymru, a grassroots feminist organisation working to protect the rights of women and girls in Wales. Following the publication of the judgment of the Supreme Court on 16 April, we are keen to know what steps Welsh Government are taking as a result of the confirmation that the meaning of the terms ‘sex’, ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in the Equality Act 2010 relates to biological sex, and not to gender identity or having a gender-recognition certificate (GRC).

We have written separately to the First Minister regarding existing and proposed legislation, policy and guidance; but given your responsibilities as the principal accountable officer for the Welsh Government in the exercise of its functions – including as an employer – we are interested in how you are reviewing the implications of the Supreme Court judgment on the work of the organisation and its statutory duties as a public body which must comply with the Equality Act.

The BBC’s 2021 investigation and the documentation available in FOI responses published on the Welsh Government website showed there have been impacts on the internal policies of Welsh Government of the decision to participate in the Stonewall Diversity Champions Scheme. This had the effect of undermining the rights of women, as well as those of holders of some other protected characteristics.

There are also implications for Welsh Government’s ability to meet its responsibilities under the Public Sector Equality Duty during the period when a misinterpretation of the Equality Act provisions had been adopted. The Strategic Equality Action Plan 2024-2028, and actions emanating from it, for example, are predicated on a conflation of ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ which was always in conflict with the Equality Act.

Taken together with the recent Sullivan Review of data, statistics and research on sex and gender, which revealed serious problems with official data due to the conflation of ‘sex’, ‘gender’ and ‘gender identity’ in data collection, there are also clear and significant implications for the information available to Welsh Government as an evidence base and to monitor effective performance.

We would be grateful if you could provide details of the approach you are using to address the above issues – including timescales where possible – and of how Welsh Government staff will be informed or trained in the correct application of the law.

In addition, we would like to know about steps Welsh Government is taking to ensure that the rights of all staff are respected and promoted, whatever their protected characteristics. We believe this can only be achieved by improved due diligence, and ensuring that organisations such as Stonewall Cymru, which have misrepresented the law and led government and other organisations into unlawful policies and practice, do not have inappropriate and undue influence in future.

We look forward to hearing from you.

Yours sincerely

On behalf of Merched Cymru