Dear Baroness Morgan
Supreme Court Judgment: For Women Scotland v Scottish Ministers
I am writing on behalf of Merched Cymru, a grassroots feminist organisation working to protect the rights of women and girls in Wales. Following the publication of the judgment of the Supreme Court on 16 April, we are keen to know what steps Welsh Government is taking in response to the confirmation that the meaning of the terms ‘sex’, ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in the Equality Act 2010 relates to biological sex, and not to gender identity or having a gender-recognition certificate (GRC).
As you are aware, a number of Welsh Government policies, action plans and proposed policy and legislation across many Ministerial portfolios were developed when the Welsh Government chose to endorse an alternative interpretation of the legislation which has now been confirmed to be incorrect. The impact of this on education, safeguarding, domestic abuse, health, social care and equality policy has been considerable.
In addition, as the BBC’s 2021 investigation and the FOI responses published on the Welsh Government website showed, there have been impacts on the internal policies of Welsh Government as an employer and to the recording of accurate statistics (see also the Sullivan Review). There are also implications for Welsh Government’s ability to meet its responsibilities under the Public Sector Equality Duty. The Strategic Equality Action Planning process, and actions emanating from it, for example, are predicated on a conflation of ‘sex’ and ‘gender’ which was always in conflict with the Equality Act.
We would be grateful if you could outline the approach Welsh Ministers are taking to reviewing all existing and proposed policy and guidance to address any misleading advice or information, especially where those may lead to failures to comply with the law.
In addition, we would be interested to know your response to the following questions:
- Do you agree with the UK Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, that the Supreme Court judgment is to be welcomed?
- Will Welsh Government funding stream requirements be changed to ensure compliance with the Equality Act as clarified by the SC judgment?
- Will you be distancing yourself from Stonewall and other organisations that have misrepresented the law and led government and other organisations into unlawful policies and practice?
Finally, we hope you will be unequivocal in your condemnation of violent slogans and threats directed at women at the protests in Swansea and Cardiff following the Supreme Court judgment and will ensure that misinformation about the validity or likely impact of the clarification of the law – as it has always been – is addressed.
We look forward to hearing from you.
Yours sincerely
On behalf of Merched Cymru

