Dear Baroness Morgan
It is now nearly three months since the Supreme Court ruled on the meaning of ‘sex’ in the Equality Act 2010.
Despite your unequivocal assurance that Welsh Government will be complying with the law, we have yet to see any action regarding the provision and protection of single sex services and spaces.
In response to our letters in April regarding the judgment, the Permanent Secretary, the Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, and the Business Team responding on behalf of the Health Minister all claimed a need to wait for the EHRC to publish its guidance before taking action.
This is not the case.
Baroness Falkner, chair of the EHRC, has made it clear that public bodies should not wait for the guidance before taking action.
The UK Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, has stated that “All guidance of whatever kind needs to be consistent with the ruling and we need to get to that position as soon as possible.”
The law is clear and Welsh Government is bound by the Public Sector Equality Duty to
Put an end to unlawful behaviour that is banned by the Equality Act 2010, including discrimination, harassment and victimisation.
We urge the Welsh Government to:
- Issue a public statement that it accepts that single-sex toilets and changing facilities must be provided on the basis of biological sex – mixed-sex facilities can be provided in addition to these so everyone’s privacy and dignity can be protected.
- Immediately suspend any guidance that permits trans identifying people to access single-sex spaces provided for the opposite sex – this would include Welsh Government’s HR guidance and procedures on trans inclusion and transitioning at work (February 2025), which states in clear contradiction to the judgment, ‘The Welsh Government’s policy position is that trans women are women, trans men are men, and non-binary identities are valid’.
- Issue a statement requiring all public bodies and service providers in Wales to take immediate action on single-sex facilities to comply with the law.
You will be aware that the Scottish Government faced the threat of legal action from human rights charity Sex Matters, before conceding that there was no requirement for duty bearers to wait for the EHRC code of practice, and that it was now taking action to implement the ruling.
The Welsh Government is currently leaving itself open to similar action. By failing to implement the ruling, it is behaving unlawfully with all the attendant legal, financial and reputational risks this presents.
It is also contributing to a climate of confusion, fear and misunderstanding following a definitive Supreme Court judgment that clarifies the law and ensures that everyone’s rights are balanced.
Merched Cymru will continue to monitor closely the Welsh Government’s actions regarding the ruling and would value a meeting with you or a senior representative.

