Dear Ms Neagle
I write on behalf of Merched Cymru, a grassroots feminist group working to protect and promote the rights of women and girls in Wales, in relation to the Supreme Court judgment of 16 April 2025. The judgment clarified that the meaning of the terms ‘sex’, ‘man’ and ‘woman’ in the Equality Act relates to biological sex, and not to gender identity or having a gender-recognition certificate (GRC).
Schools need clear guidance that they can accommodate aspects of children’s identity exploration (changes of informal nicknames, gender neutral uniform rules, no tolerance of bullying) but must respect the boundaries of sex where it is relevant – sports, toilets, changing rooms, sleeping accommodation – in order to respect the law, and the rights of all the children, as well as safeguarding.
Will you ensure that the long-delayed schools trans-inclusion guidance supports schools to comply with the law and keep children safe?
In the meantime, will you issue a clear statement to local authorities that they are expected to comply with the law?
Further, it is now abundantly clear that much of the confusion regarding sex, gender and gender identity within education policy and elsewhere has its roots in the deliberate misrepresentation of equality law by Stonewall and other organisations advocating for trans rights.
For example, the Stonewall-badged trans inclusion toolkit developed by the Central South Consortium, and still in use in a slightly updated version in the Vale of Glamorgan, advised that schools must allow children access to the toilets, changing rooms, sports and sleeping accommodation of their choice.
The policy making process for the schools guidance has relied heavily on the input of trans advocacy organisations, whose advice has led organisations into unlawful policies, while organisations taking a sex-realist perspective have been excluded.
Will you ensure that the development of the policy, and the consultation process, are balanced, and unbiased?
I look forward to your response.

